OM in the News: China’s Dominance in the Rare Earth Supply Chain

The minerals, metals and rare earths needed for the green and digital transitions are shaping up to be the oil of this century—complete with a race to secure raw materials and production capacity at home or in friendly locations.

China has the early lead, writes The Wall Street Journal (March 9, 2023), dominating production of many critical materials including lithium and rare earths. Over the past years, China secured deposits around the world and invested heavily in the domestic manufacturing of clean technologies such as electric vehicles, batteries and solar panels. As the graph shows, China has a clear lead in the rare earth supply chain.

Western nations have now made it a top priority to secure a supply of these materials. The West has been tempted by the economic opportunity but also chastened by the recent semiconductor shortages, Europe’s efforts to replace Russian energy imports, and Beijing’s support for Russia after it invaded Ukraine.

Going back to President Trump, the U.S. signed executive orders for critical minerals– and has had recent success in starting to build local supply chains. The European Union’s latest effort—a Critical Minerals Act—aims to kick-start mining, processing and recycling in that region. There is one area where the EU act is right on the money—accelerating permitting. Permitting has been a key challenge for companies investing across geographies and sectors including mining, processing, power lines, solar, wind and batteries. In the EU, ambitious permitting reforms appears to be be the biggest hurdle to getting political agreement on that bloc’s local production of EV batteries. Limiting or overriding local opposition is rarely a vote-winning stance.

We may also get a G-7 critical minerals buyers club of the Group of Seven advanced democracies to secure supply from mineral rich countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America. Reduced Chinese supply—if it happens—will force Western policy makers and voters to face the trade-off between the carbon benefits of wind energy or electric vehicles and the environmental and pollution costs associated with manufacturing those technologies.

Classroom discussion questions:

1. Why are countries and companies so concerned about “rare earths”?
2. What is the main benefit in dominating the mineral supply chain?