OM in the News: Human Rights Abuse Investigated by Nestle

Most of Thailand's seafood workers are migrants brought in illegally by traffickers
Most of Thailand’s seafood workers are migrants brought in illegally by traffickers

The seafood industry in Thailand suffers from widespread labor and human rights abuses, exposing virtually all American and European companies that buy seafood from there to the “endemic risk” of having these problems as part of their supply chain, according to a report just released by the food giant Nestlé. The report cataloged deceptive recruitment practices, hazardous working conditions and violence on fishing boats and in processing factories. It also faulted the industry for taking insufficient steps to ensure that workers were not underage. (Nestle had been sued in August, with the claim that its Fancy Feast cat food was the product of forced labor, reports The New York Times–Nov. 24, 2015).

Most of Thailand’s seafood workers are migrants from neighboring Cambodia or Myanmar; they were provided fake documents and often sold to boat captains. On fishing boats, these workers routinely faced limited access to medical care for injuries or infection; worked 16-hour days, 7 days a week; endured chronic sleep deprivation; and suffered from an insufficient supply of water for drinking, showering or cooking. “Sometimes, the net is too heavy, and workers get pulled into the water and just disappear,” one Burmese worker said. “When someone dies, he gets thrown into the water.”

Workers sometimes went a year before receiving any wages, and some faced physical and verbal abuse if they did not meet production quotas. Nestlé said that next year it would announce new requirements for all potential suppliers as well as the details of a plan for hiring auditors to check for compliance with new rules. Because Nestlé is the world’s biggest food company, it is seen as a leader in the industry, and could have a positive impact on the whole industry by raising the bar on labor protection.

Classroom discussion questions:

  1. Why did Nestle issue this report?
  2. What can be done to stop worker abuse?

OM in the News: Your Cat, Slavery, and the Seafood Supply Chain

Living quarters on the boats are hot and cramped, with crew sleeping just 2 hours between shifts
Living quarters on the boats are hot and cramped, with crew sleeping just 2 hours between shifts

If your cat eats Meow Mix, Fancy Feast, or Iams, there is a good chance you are supporting “sea slaves”, men and boys put in forced labor in Thailand for cheap fish, reports The New York Times (July 27, 2015) in a front page expose.  The U.S. is the biggest customer of Thai fish, and pet food is among the fastest growing exports from Thailand. The average pet cat eats 30 pounds of fish per year, double that of a typical American.

Though there is growing pressure for more accountability in seafood companies’ supply chains, virtually no attention has focused on the labor that supplies the seafood that people and pets eat. Much of the catch is destined for canneries such as Thai Union Frozen Products, that country’s largest seafood company, which shipped 28 million pounds of pet food to the U.S. in 2014.

The misery endured by sea slaves is not uncommon in the maritime world. Labor abuse at sea can be so severe that its victims might as well be captives from a bygone era. Those who fled recounted horrific violence: the sick cast overboard, the defiant beheaded, the insubordinate sealed for days below deck in a dark, fetid fishing hold. The harsh practices have intensified in recent years because of lax maritime labor laws and an insatiable global demand for seafood.

Officials point to a greater reliance on long-haul fishing, in which vessels stay at sea, sometimes for years, far from the reach of authorities. Government intervention is rare. While the U.N. prohibits forced labor, Thailand does little to counter misconduct on the high seas. U.N. and rights organizations accuse Thai officials of taking bribes from traffickers, and migrants often report being rescued by Thai police from one smuggler only to be resold to another.

Classroom discussion questions:

1.Why can’t pet food makers like Purina eliminate this worker abuse?

2. Describe the pet seafood supply chain.