Here is a great article that ties into our new chapter, “Sustainability in the Supply Chain” and its Example S2 (see p. 195) dealing with life cycle ownership/break-even analysis. The Wall Street Journal (Oct.30, 2013) writes: “Operators of some of the largest U.S. truck fleets, including Lowe’s , P&G, and UPS are accelerating a shift to natural gas fueled trucks, betting on new engine technology that promises to drop the cost of shifting from diesel fuel.” Lowe’s wants its delivery company to shift all of its several hundred trucks to natural gas by 2017. P&G already has 7% of its trucks on gas and could reach as much as 20% within two years. UPS says it plans to buy 1,000 natural gas trucks by the end of next year. FedEx plans to shift 30% of its long-distance trucks to natural gas over the next decade.
The nation’s supply of relatively cheap natural gas is helping spur this shift. So are new natural gas engines that can power heavy-duty trucks that weigh up to 80,000 pounds. About 5% of all heavy-duty trucks sold next year will run on natural gas, up from 1% this year. Barriers to wider use are coming down, driven by the relatively low-cost of compressed natural gas, or CNG, which sells for about $1.50 less a gallon than its equivalent in diesel fuel, which averages about $3.87. Natural gas also produces less carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and sulfur-based pollution than diesel or gasoline per mile driven. Diesel-engine trucks get 5-7 mpg and average 100,000 miles a year.
Waste Management, Inc. has converted 15% of its 22,000 truck fleet to natural gas, and 90% of its future purchases will be natural gas fueled, helping it save $15,000-$20,000 a year per truck, a 2-year payoff. The cost of the natural gas vehicles is still an issue. CNG trucks cost $40,000-$50,000 more than a diesel truck, which costs about $120,000. In large fleets, that premium could add millions of dollars to equipment cost.
Classroom discussion questions:
1. Why is the switch to CNG trucks an OM issue?
2. What factors are driving the change?