OM in the News: Monitoring Employees Who Work From Home

As we note in Chapter 10, labor is a costly component of most OM activities. So as we have moved to computer-oriented tasks, rather than manual tasks, new tools for evaluating productivity have been developed.  Now with millions of employees suddenly doing these tasks from home, more managers want to know how employees spend their time, writes The Wall Street Journal (April 20, 2020).

One new technology provides the ability to install a tool that takes computer screenshots of home-based employees every 10 minutes and records how much time they spend on certain activities. It gives managers productivity scores for remote workers or detailed reports on which tasks consume their days. Other tools are designed to catch employees who might be more tempted to download files from the company or violate security rules. At Teramind, whose technology can give employers a live look at employees’ computer screens or recordings of videos of their activities, inquiries have recently tripled, and 1/3 of the company’s 2,000 clients have requested additional licenses to track more users.

One S. Carolina manager states: “This is not a witch hunt to try and find the guy who spends 20 minutes a day on the news. The tool to track web browsing and time spent on work-related apps will pay longer-term dividends.We’re able to get a lot more granular insights into how much time they’re spending on individual tasks. Each staffer has access to their own data and can see how their own productivity levels fluctuate.”

Employers have wide legal latitude to use tracking tools, though the products can test employees’ threshold for privacy concerns “Frankly, employees already have an incentive to be productive, just by mere fact of wanting to keep their jobs,” says one Cornell prof.

Classroom discussion questions:

  1. Are there ethical and privacy issues that need to be addressed here?
  2. Why is such software now an important OM tool?

OM in the News (and Video): Quality of Life at Amazon

Amazon's warehouse in Wales.
Amazon’s warehouse in Wales.

On its home territory, Amazon.com is routinely hailed as a jobs machine,” writes The New York Times (Dec.2, 2013).  Thanks to its warehouse building spree, it is hiring tens of thousands of workers, plus many more for the holidays. President Obama has called Amazon “a great example of what’s possible… the kind of approach that we need from America’s businesses.”

The recession might have cut deeper in Europe, making the question of new jobs even more crucial, but the attitude there is much cooler toward Amazon and its high-tech ways. In Germany, there is continuing labor strife. France is erecting barriers against the company’s aggressive discounting. And in Britain, the warehouses have been compared, in a story in The Financial Times, with a “slave camp.”

That shocking charge resurfaced in the latest investigation when a BBC reporter, Adam Littler, briefly went to work undercover at Amazon’s Wales warehouse. His report, broadcast last week on the show “Panorama,” (click here for the 1/2 hour video) showed him hustling to keep up with the demands of his hand-held scanner, which gave him only a few moments to find each product. In his 10-hour night shift, Littler said: “I managed to walk or hobble nearly 11 miles. We are machines, we are robots, we plug our scanner in, we’re holding it, but we might as well be plugging it into ourselves.”

Michael Marmot, a labor expert identified by the BBC as “one of Britain’s leading experts on stress at work,” told the TV show that with “the characteristics of this type of job, the evidence shows increased risk of mental illness and physical illness.” Amazon’s own expert disagrees, of course, and we have to question the shock value displayed in the video. The real question for your students is how are labor standards set–and whether they are fair to both the company and employees. For another view altogether of Amazon’s sophisticated warehouses in the US, watch this 3 minute video.

Classroom discussion questions:

1. How can labor standards for this job be set (see Chapter 10)?

2. What are the ergonomic issues addressed in the video?